|
Democracy
in Action
| A public vote occurred at the IDNO concerning a motion
proposed by Mr. Karl E. Peters to rescind the Charter
and to restructure the IDNO.
The vote closed on Wednesday October 31st,
2001 at GMT 00:00. Votes issued at that date were:
Supporting the motion : 15
Blair, Hugh
Buchanan, Hugh
Cameron, Grace
Cottone, Tom
Gardner, Andy
Jarrell, Ron
Kelly, Kevin
Lynch, John
Lynch, Darryl H G
Moriarity, Michael
Nasal, Carl
Peters , Karl E.
Thornton, Bradley G.
Wallwork, Nathan
Walsh, William X.
Objecting the motion: 20
Ayala, Fernando L.
Baron, Domingo
Berglie, Steve
Carter III; James A.
Cooney, Chris
Freed, Ken
Heather, Earl
Hyde, Peter
Kent, Eileen
Lee, Joseph
Morfin, Jean Francois C.
Nair, Dinesh
Pennington, Adam
Shaw, Greg
Sotiropoulos, Sotiris
Stauffer, Paul
Svensson, Paul
Teernstra, Joop
Waller, Brad
West, Jessica
In addition to this Larry Robbins, Member has objected
but not in the proper voting format. Proposed to resend
his vote he has not responded.
Two non Members, Mrs. Joanna Lane and Davis Schutt
have objected.
The motion has not been adopted.
This vote has been carried without major disruption
nor personal disputes. It has shown the ability of
the IDNO Members to proceed in an orderly way under
difficult circumstances. Its a proof of the maturity
of this group. As acting as a main polling officer
for this vote I thank the Members of the Polling Committee
and of the IDNO for their cooperation and nice assistance.
Jefsey Morfin
IDNO, Acting Polling Committee.
|
|
Text of the Motion:
Whereas the IDNO has been unable to
become a cohesive group or organization over the last
two years,
Whereas the IDNO has not been able to achieve critical
mass either in total members or in active participation,
Whereas the IDNO has historical baggage which will
only continue to weigh it down more at the expense
of domain holders' representation in the DNSO,
Whereas no other constituency is an organization,
and the bylaws do not provide for an organization
being recognized as a constituency,
Whereas the IDNO is probably better suited to be
an advocacy group on behalf of domain holders,
Whereas the IDNO's founder is well suited as a "lobbyist"
type advocate for domain holders,
Therefore by it resolved that:
1) The charter be rescinded.
2) This organization be reformed as a consumer rights
type organization created to lobby for greater representation
of domain holders in the ICANN process, and to advocate
for policies that
strengthen the rights of domain holders. The organization
does not seek to become a constituency in any fashion,
but as a not for profit does seek to advocate for
the registrant's constituency and
other representations for domain registrants in the
ICANN process.
3) That this organization consider formally changing
its name to the Cyberspace Association and dropping
the IDNO moniker completely.
4) That this organization explore the possibility
of becoming a legally registered non-profit organization
in New Zealand or elsewhere.
5) That an initial executive committee of 3 be appointed
to include the organization's founder, the last chair
of the IDNO Lists as elected in the last election,
(or comparable person if this specific
individual is not available) and at least one member
of the group perceived by Joop to be "IDNO Opposition".
6) That Joop be appointed representative of the Cyberspace
Association for the purposes of ICANN Board meetings,
and be directed to advocate for the creation of an
open domain registrants
constituency on behalf of the Cyberspace Association
and it's members.
7) That Joop be appointed temporary web master of
the organization, with the power to delegate this
duty to a third party with the approval of the executive
committee.
8) That this act will put the IDNO and its history
and controversies in the past once and for all, and
that all members agree to let the entire issue pass
without any further comment publicly or privately,
and that this include the members of the executive
committee, and that attempting to bring up the IDNO
history and issues again is grounds for recall by
the list members of any initial executive committee
member or representative. The entire IDNO issue is
to be considered dropped, and not relevant to our
further work. Anyone who cannot accept this and abide
by it is to be considered ineligible for any leadership
or elected position within the Cyberspace Association.
9) That the association act by on list consensus
processes wherever possible, with the executive committee
ruling where no consensus is clear from the list activity.
|
List Chair Chair Nomination open
(September, October, November 2001)
Nominations are open from Nov 3. and end Nov 10
00:00 GMT.
| According to the IDNO Charter, the Acting Polling
Committee by votes of M. Sotiris Sotiropoulos and Mr.
Jean-François C. Morfin, Mr. Matthew Enger absentee,
has decided to open a seven days nomination period for
the designation of the IDNO Chair, starting this Saturday
November 3rd at 00:00 GMT and closing on Saturday
November 10th at 00:00 GMT
Participate to that nomination and election the Members
of the IDNO-DISCUSS list.
Acceptance and Elections periods will be as per the
Charter published on the IDNO site http://www.idno.org
The nominations and the vote will be carried publicly
and managed in full transparency in front of the idno-discuss
mailing list.
Jefsey
|
| candidate |
nominated by |
seconded by |
accepted |
| Sotiris Sotiropoulos |
Joop Teernstra |
Jessica West |
yes |
| Karl Peters |
Matthew Enger |
Michael Moriarty, Hugh Buchanan |
|
| Joanna Lane |
Darryl Lynch |
Joop Teernstra, Earl Heather |
|
| |
|
|
|
Vote of 19 August 2001 on Joining the NCDNHC
| In Favour of joining |
33 |
84.6% |
| Against joining |
5 |
12.8% |
| Undecided |
1 |
2.5% |
Polling Committee: Term ending 30
July, 2001: Sotiris Sotiropoulos, Jean Francois Morfin and
Matthew Enger
List
Assembly Chair Election
| |
nominated by: |
seconded by |
|
Greg Burton
declined
|
Joop Teernstra |
Jefsey Morfin |
|
Darryl Lynch
Acceptance withdrawn
|
Roeland Meyer, Karl E. Peters |
Sri Narra
|
| Rod Dixon J.D. |
Joop Teernstra, Jessica West |
Domingo Barón, Jefsey Morfin |
Polling
Committee
election
David
Farrar proposal (seconded):
- Nominations
close 1 feb.
- acceptances
(and pictures) in 8 feb.
- Campainging
- 22 Feb.
elections
- 26 Feb.
Poll closes
|
|
nominated
by |
seconded
by |
accepted |
| Joop
Teernstra |
Domingo
Barón, Marc Schneiders |
Jessica
West, Jefsey Morfin |
yes |
| Matthew
Enger |
Paul
Svensson |
Domingo
Baron, David Farrar |
yes |
| Sotiris
Sotiropoulos |
Joop
Teernstra |
Jefsey
Morfin, Jessica West |
`yes |
| Johannes
Chiang |
Joop
Teernstra |
|
|
| David
Farrar |
Joop
Teernstra, Domingo Baron |
Matthew
Enger, Dassa, Jefsey Morfin, Marc Schneiders |
yes |
Elections for vacant ExeCom Positions
| |
nominated by |
seconded by |
accepted |
| |
|
|
|
| David Farrar |
Jefsey |
Joop |
|
| Sotiris Sotiropoulos |
Jefsey |
Joop |
|
| Rod Dixon |
Jefsey |
Joop |
|
| Jess West |
Jefsey |
Joop |
|
| Aaron Schmiedel |
Jefsey |
Joop |
|
| Hongjie Li |
Jefsey |
Joop |
|
| Paul Svensson |
Jefsey |
Joop |
|
| Dinesh Nair |
Jefsey |
Joop |
|
The
results of the Elections that closed on December 6, 2000 are:
| Number of Votes cast: 35 |
|
Executive
Committee
|
|
|
votes |
| Hong
Jie Li |
Joop
Teernstra |
Dave
Chu |
9 |
| Francesco
Ravanelli |
Joop
Teernstra |
Marc
Schneiders |
13
|
| Robin
Miller |
Chris
Streatfield |
Marc
Schneiders, Jefsey Morfin |
19 |
| Jefsey
Morfin |
Chris
Streatfield |
Marc
Schneiders,Roeland Meyer, Francesco Ravanelli |
19 |
| Srikanth
Narra |
Chris
Streatfield |
Joop
Teernstra |
17 |
| Joop
Teernstra |
Chris
Streatfield |
Marc
Schneiders |
23 |
| Roeland
Meyer |
Chris
Streatfield |
Marc
Schneiders, Jefsey Morfin |
17 |
| Arnold
Gehring |
Chris
Streatfield |
Roeland
Meyer |
24 |
| Marc
Schneiders |
Chris
Streatfield |
Francesco
Ravanelli,Roeland Meyer, Robin Miller |
24 |
| Membership
Committee |
nominated by |
seconded by |
acceptance |
| Arnold Gehring |
Joop Teernstra |
Roeland Meyer |
accepted |
| Keith Weiner |
Joop Teernstra |
Jefsey Morfin,
Robin Miller |
accepted |
Keith Weiner and Arnold Gehring have been elected unopposed
| PollingCommittee |
nominated by |
seconded by |
acceptance |
| Dr Johannes
Chiang |
Joop Teernstra |
Francesco Ravanelli |
accepted
|
| Larry Wang |
Joop Teernstra |
Robin Miller |
|
The acceptance
of Dr Chiang was not made on the public list and was therefore ruled
unconstitutional.
New elections
for Polling Committee will be scheduled later.
***
IDNO Representatives elected
2
November, 2000
Dennis
Schaefer - 18 votes (54.55%)
Dinesh
Nair - 19 votes (57.58%)
Joop
Teernstra - 20 votes (60.61%)
33
members cast their votes
***
17
September, 2000
The
work of the Charter Committee has come to a successful conclusion and
the Charter has been presented for ratification
to 191 members.
43
members voted for Acceptance, 3 voted against.
The
Rules of the Charter have now superseded the rules of the Re-Railing
proposal (RRP) that have served the CA/idno in the interim.
We
have proceeded with the election of a List Assembly Chair (Domingo Baron),
who was nominated by Karl Auerbach, and seconded by Chris Streatfield
and Joop Teernstra.
Previous
Election for List-Chair
Dinesh
Nair had been elected Chair for 3 months
(until
May 18, 2000)
| |
seconded
by |
Number
of votes |
| Dinesh
Nair |
Chris
Streatfield,Joop Teernstra,Domingo Baron |
11 |
| Domingo
Baron |
Chris
Streatfield, Joop Teernstra |
5 |
| Andy
Gardner |
William
Walsh, Matthew Enger |
7 |
The elections
started on Feb. 13 , 12:00 GMT and ended on Feb. 17 12:00 GMT
Voting
was restricted to the CA/IDNO members that were subscribed to the idno-discuss
list as per 27 January, 2000 when the election was first announced (29
voters--the voters' roll has been published on the idno-discuss list)
***
The
Re-railing proposal of Peter Hyde has been ratified by the Members on
21 October. Together with the ratified part of the Charter (artt. 1
to 4) this is the only "law" the IDNO has. Draft, agreement
and ratification of the rest of the Charter has the highest priority.
Elections
for Polling and Charter committee have been held closing Nov. 16, 1999
The
results:
Election of the Charter Committee
Total
number of voters: 37
| Name |
Number of Votes |
Percentage |
| Dennis Schaefer |
21 |
56.7568 % |
| Chris Streatfield |
17 |
45.9459 % |
| Karl E.Peters |
20 |
54.0541 % |
| Dinesh Nair |
18 |
48.6486 % |
| Joop Teernstra |
19 |
51.3514 % |
| Bradley Thornton |
12 |
32.4324 % |
| Paul Svensson |
15 |
40.5405 % |
Elected
for the 3 person Charter Committee: Dennis Schaefer, Karl Peters and
Joop Teernstra.
In case of any vacancy on the committee, the vacancy will be fulfilled
by the next candidate in order of votes received. (i.e. Dinesh Nair,
Chris Streatfield and Paul Svensson)
After the
resignation of Karl E.Peters, Dinesh Nair has filled the vacancy.
Election
of Polling Committee
Total
number of voters: 31
Number
of Votes, Percentage
| Chris Streatfield |
24 |
77.4194 % |
| Joop Teernstra |
28 |
90.3226 % |
| Dominic Baron |
22 |
70.9677 % |
Last updated 6 November, 2001
Please find earlier
voting results and nominations under this link
|